Should a Juvenile be Tried as an Adult?

It's time to expand your UPSC knowledge base with our daily dose of Current Affairs. Today we will discuss should a Juvenile be tried as an Adult or not.

Keep on reading as we dig deeper into the Juvenile Justice Act and enhance your UPSC CSE preparation.

For Prelims: Juvenile Justice Board (JJB), the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR)

For Mains: Juvenile Justice, Child Rights, Juvenile Justice Act 2015

Context

The Supreme Court (SC) has recently asked the central government, the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR), and the State Commission for Protection of Child Rights (SCPCR) to assist and facilitate the Juvenile Justice Boards (JJBs) in determining whether a juvenile should be tried for a heinous offense as an adult.

Also, read our yesterday’s edition of Current Affairs on the Har Ghar Tiranga Campaign and Flag Code of India

Probable Question

Recently the Supreme Court of India asked the central government to draft guidelines for determining whether a juvenile should be tried as an adult in cases of heinous offenses. Critically comment on the provisions of the Juvenile Justice Act of 2015. 

About the Law on Trying a Juvenile as an Adult

• In 2015, the Lok Sabha passed a revamped Juvenile Justice Bill.
• It allowed minors of 16-18 years old to be tried as adults if they commit heinous crimes, for which the minimum punishment is 7 years imprisonment.
• Section 15 of The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act (JJ Act) says;
  • The JJB is required to “conduct a preliminary assessment with regard to his mental and physical capacity to commit a heinous offense.
  • Assessment should be done within 3 months from the date of the first production of the child before the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB). 
• As per the apex court, the JJB would have to mandatorily seek the assistance of experts, in case it doesn’t comprise a practicing professional with a degree in child psychology or child psychiatry.
• Imprisonment: If the child is tried as an adult, the sentence can go up to life imprisonment, whereas for a juvenile, the maximum sentence is only 3 years in a special home.

Treating a Juvenile as an Adult

The cases of committing a heinous crime by a minor of 16-18 years, must be transferred to the children’s court, which decides;

• Under Section 19 of the Juvenile Justice Act whether there is a need for a trial of the child as an adult.
• It ensures that the child in conflict will only be transferred to jail, once he/she reaches the age of 21, before it, they must be sent to a “place of safety”.
• It can order the conditional release of the child after the age of 21 years. 

JJB’s Call in absence of any guidelines to try the child as an adult

• The Supreme Court said that physical maturity, cognitive abilities, and social and emotional competencies, should be considered to determine a child as an adult. 
• It is of the view that mental capacity should not be equated with an understanding of the consequences of the offense, as they are likely to be influenced by emotion rather than reason.
• The “consequences” as per Section 15 of the Act would not just be confined to the immediate consequence, but also the far-reaching consequences in the future.

News Source: The Indian Express

If you are targeting UPSC CSE 2023, then here's a video you must watch on crucial books for IAS preparation, by Vivek Singh Sir, our Economy faculty:

Download the PrepLadder app to study from India’s top UPSC faculty and transform your UPSC preparation from the Beginner level to the Advanced level.

You can also join our Telegram channel for UPSC coaching and to stay updated with the latest information about the UPSC exam.

Own Your Dream

Team PrepLadder